In the world of entertainment, casting choices can make or break a show's success. One such casting decision that has piqued the interest of fans is why Roseanne Barr turned down the role of Peggy Bundy in Married with Children. This classic sitcom, which aired from 1987 to 1997, starred Ed O'Neill as Al Bundy and Katey Sagal as his wife Peggy.
Barr was offered the role of Peggy before it eventually went to Sagal. While many speculated that financial reasons were behind her rejection, there were other factors at play. Here's what exactly transpired.
Was Roseanne Barr Supposed To Appear In Married With Children?
Some fans believe Barr would have been a perfect fit for the irreverent Bundy family. Others maintain that her absence from the series was ultimately for the best.
There are several reasons why Barr may have been considered for a role on Married With Children. For one thing, her brash and outspoken persona would certainly have meshed well with the show's unapologetic humor.
Additionally, Barr had already made a name for herself in the world of comedy by the time Married With Children premiered in 1987. However, despite these factors, Barr never actually appeared on the show in any capacity.
According to Showbiz Cheat Sheet, Barr was heavily considered by the showrunners to play Peggy. They even wrote the initial character based on Barr's personality and sense of humor, although the Peggy fans would come to adore was written much more based on Sagal's humor and charm. However, Barr did turn the role down almost immediately.
This left producers scrambling to find a suitable actress for the role, and they eventually settled on Sagal. However, it is interesting to consider how different the show may have been if Barr had been able to take on the part.
Sagal brought a unique energy and flair to Peggy that cannot be denied. Her portrayal of the character was both hilarious and endearing, making Peggy one of television’s most iconic moms. She perfectly captured Peggy’s sassy attitude and over-the-top fashion sense while also showcasing her vulnerability as a wife and mother.
It’s hard to imagine anyone else playing this role so perfectly.
However, it’s worth noting that Barr may have brought a different perspective to Peggy Bundy had she been able to take on the part. Given Barr’s own brash personality and tendency towards controversy, it would have been fascinating to see how she would have interpreted some of Peggy’s more outrageous moments.
Sagal’s performance was nothing short of brilliant – so much so that it earned her four Emmy nominations throughout the show’s run. Her chemistry with Ed O’Neill's Ted Bundy was palpable and helped establish Married with Children as one of TV’s most beloved sitcoms.
It is also worth considering other casting choices beyond just those for Peggy Bundy.
For example, David Garrison originally played Steve Rhoades before leaving after four seasons due to creative differences with the show’s producers. He was replaced by Ted McGinley, who played Jefferson D’Arcy. While fans were initially skeptical of this change, McGinley’s performance won them over and he became a fan favorite.
Similarly, Christina Applegate was relatively unknown when she was cast as Kelly Bundy, but her performance quickly made her a household name. She brought an infectious energy to the role that perfectly complemented Sagal’s more subdued performance as Peggy. The cast of Married With Children has become iconic in their own right, despite the actors going in vastly different directions after the show's ending.
So Married With Children may have missed out on Barr's tremendous acting, but they certainly rebounded with a great cast of lesser-known actors at that point in time. But why did Barr turn down such an important role?
Why Did Roseanne Barr Turn Down Starring In Married With Children As Peggy Bundy?
When Barr was offered the role of Peggy Bundy in the hit sitcom Married... with Children, it was a dream come true for the aspiring actress. However, to everyone's surprise, she turned down the opportunity to play one of television's most iconic characters. The question that lingers is why?
.jpg?q=50&fit=crop&w=740&dpr=1.5)
There are several factors that contributed to Barr's decision not to appear on the show. Firstly, it is important to note that Barr had already achieved significant success with her own show, Roseanne. Accoding to TV Guide, the sitcom premiered in 1988 and quickly became a hit with viewers, earning high ratings and critical acclaim. As such, Barr likely felt little motivation or need to appear on another show.
The choice to remain focused on Rosanne turned out to be a perfect one for all those involved. Roseanne premiered in 1988 and quickly became a cultural phenomenon, running for nine seasons until 1997. The show, created by Barr and Matt Williams, followed the daily lives of the working-class Conner family in the fictional town of Lanford, Illinois. Roseanne went on to become one of the most successful television shows of all time.
The recent reboot may not have been that well-received, but Barr's had her own thoughts and feelings about that. Things got so bad that the show actually got rid of her before it's ending. None of that drama takes away from the success of the original series, or even the reboot for that matter. It was the most-watched TV series of 2018.
One of the most intriguing aspects of Barr's decision to turn down the role of Peg Bundy on Married with Children is her declining interest in pure acting. While it may seem counterintuitive for someone who was actively pursuing a career in Hollywood at the time, Barr was already a showrunner and star of the successful sitcom. It's not hard to see why she wouldn't want to play a backseat role in another series, regardless of how popular it would become.
Overall, Roseanne was successful in many ways beyond just ratings or awards. It was the right choice for Barr at the time, and it would pave the way for another successful sitcom mom to rule 90s media. Sagal's portrayal of Peggy Bundy was amazing for the time, and fans still got to see Barr play the titular character of her own show. Really, this turned out to be a win-win situation for everyone.