15 Women A-Rod Secretly Dated (2 He Wished He Did)

There have been a number of Major League Baseball players that have come and gone without much fanfare. Baseball is a sport that is incredibly difficult to succeed in and there are numerous professionals that simply couldn't go the distance. This fact makes the success stories that much more special. A great example is Alex Rodriguez, the former professional baseball player that was known for his stellar shortstop and third baseman skills. While he played for the Seattle Mariners and the Texas Rangers, he's known best for his time with the New York Yankees.

He garnered the nickname, A-Rod, and he also garnered a reputation for being a bit of a ladies man. Although his time as a professional baseball player came to an end, he never really withdrew from the limelight. He's seen huge success as a businessman and television personality and he's also maintained his popularity with the ladies. Let's take a look at 15 women A-Rod secretly dated and 2 that he wished he'd dated and see if his time flipping through his dating Rolodex has finally come to an end.

17 Jessica Canseco

via Pop Culture

Jessica Canseco is the ex-wife of the famed baseball professional, Jose Canseco. She was famously a former Hooters waitress prior to entering the limelight as a baseball wife but she was definitely beautiful enough to make it in the modeling world.

When she was rumored to date A-Rod, there were some harsh words released from Jose Canseco.

16 Jennifer Lopez

via Vanity Fair

Prior to going public with their romance, A-Rod started to secretly date Jennifer Lopez. The two had a now-infamous meeting that actually started with Jennifer initiating the conversation.

The two had previously interacted from a fitness endeavor so that's how they supposedly already had each other's phone numbers. Yet, the rest is history.

15 Bethenny Frankel

via Bravo TV

A-Rod has been known for being attracted to high-powered women in business, so it should come as no surprise that he once dated Bethenny Frankel.

The two were definitely keeping things secret but she let the cat out of the bag when she appeared on Watch What Happens Live and revealed that the two went on two dates shortly after his divorce.

14 Torrie Wilson

via TheSportster

Torrie Wilson was rumored to date A-Rod for a while before the two went public with their romance in 2011. It seemed like a great match with them since she was known for wearing multiple hats, just like A-Rod.

Her acting, modeling and wrestling career seemed to be working well but that wasn't the same for their relationship, which ended after three years.

13 Cameron Diaz

via People

Alex Rodriguez and Cameron Diaz were first rumored to be dating in 2010 and officially took their romance public in May of 2010. They had a number of high-profile pictures taken of them as a couple and even one famous photo that was taken during a Super Bowl, where Diaz was seen feeding him with popcorn.

Yet, the two ultimately called it quits in September 2011.

12 Kate Hudson

via si.com

Kate Hudson and Alex Rodriguez had quite a public romance in 2009 but the pair were secretly dating as far back as 2008, with pictures surfacing of the two in Toronto.

They walked separately and tried to be a bit incognito but once the couple started to date publicly and share kisses in front of thousands of fans at games, it was obvious that the pair had been together for a while.

11 Madonna

via PopSugar

The relationship Alex Rodriguez had with Madonna was always one that seemed to puzzle the world. NY Post reported that his ex-wife "divorced him because of his relationship with Madonna," but the two never actually went public with a high-profile romantic relationship in the same way that he had done with his other famous girlfriends.

10 Anne Wojcicki

via Page Six

In March 2016, pictures surfaced of Alex Rodriguez with Anne Wojcicki, a billionaire entrepreneur. People didn't quite know what to think of this relationship since it seemed so different from all his other flings.

She was previously married to the Google co-founder, Sergey Brin, but her relationship with A-Rod never made it down the aisle.

9 Demi Moore

via Puretrend

The relationship between Demi Moore and Alex Rodriguez is a bit tricky since it was shrouded in secrecy and the timeline is a bit sketchy because of the fact that both were supposedly in other relationships.

However, the two were spotted dining out in July 2012 and she also attended a party at his house where she was photographed twerking.

8 Ella Magers

via rumorfix.com

Keeping with the blonde look that seemed to be A-Rod's type back-in-the-day, he secretly dated the model, Ella Magers. The two were linked romantically back in the fall of 2011.

However, there aren't many photographs that were taken of the pair and they never went public with their romantic relationship.

7 Joslyn Morse

via w3planet.info

While Alex Rodriguez was still married to Cynthia Scurtis, he was spotted with Joslyn Morse. The two were photographed in 2007 in Toronto and could be seen going out on the town and also going back to the team hotel.

The photographers dubbed the photographs as "Stray-Rod" and it was a huge blow to his marriage.

6 Candice Houlihan

via bureo.com.do

Back when Alex Rodriguez was still married to his wife, Cynthia Scurtis, he reportedly had a romantic relationship with Candice Houlihan. This was definitely a secret romance and Houlihan claimed that the two had only been together romantically twice, back in 2004.

Yet, she came out in support of Scurtis when the couple went through their divorce.

5 Cynthia Scurtis

via Page Six

There was a time when Alex Rodriguez was just seen as a baseball hopeful and no one could have guessed that he would go on to become the all-star baseball player and businessman that he's known as today.

During those early years, he dated Cynthia Scurtis and the couple wound up tying the knot in November 2002 but ultimately finalized their divorce in February 2009.

4 Kyna Treacy

via astonmodels.com

While Alex Rodriguez was dating Torrie Wilson, he reportedly tried to start dating the Australian bikini model, Kyna Treacy. During an ALC game against the Detroit Tigers, Kyna Treacy was enjoying the game when she caught the eye of A-Rod.

He tossed a ball to her and reportedly asked her to write her number down and toss it back (which she did).

3 Kate Quinn

via larrybrownsports.com

During the ALC game against the Detroit Tigers, Alex Rodriguez spotted two beautiful women watching the game. While the brunette was the Australian bikini model, Kyna Treacy, the blonde next to her was the model, Kate Quinn.

With A-Rod being known for having a thing for blondes, it's not surprising that he tossed a ball to her and asked for her number as well.

2 Julianne Hough (Wished He Dated)

via WallsDeks.com

In 2013, Julianne Hough had just gone through a highly publicized breakup with Ryan Seacrest. With her back in the single market, A-Rod reportedly took a fancy to her.

The National Enquirer quoted a close friend of A-Rod that stated, "Alex thinks he could really hit it off with Julianne." He was definitely known for being partial to blondes but she reportedly shot him down.

1 Zoe Gregory (Wished He Dated)

via InTouch Weekly

Zoe Gregory is a model that claimed that Alex Rodriguez had been texting her repeatedly from December 2018 to January 22. She gave an interview with U.K.'s The Sun and revealed that he was fervently trying to spark up a romantic relationship.

This came just two months before he proposed to Jennifer Lopez but Gregory claimed, "He was being a dirty dog."

Sources: National Enquirer, Bravo TV, Page Six, People, Pop Sugar, NY Post, Daily Mail, InTouch Weekly, The Sun

More in Pop Culture