In season 1 of YOU on Netflix, we saw the character of Joe Goldberg fall in love with a beautiful college student named Guinevere Beck. He ended up being really toxic in her life, locking her up in a cage, and ultimately killing her (although there’s plenty of speculation that she might still be alive.) In season 2 of YOU, Joe Goldberg fell for a new young woman named Love Quinn. By the end of the season, fans discovered the fact that Love Quinn was actually crazier than Joe Goldberg himself!
The last episode of season 2 alluded to the fact that Joe Goldberg has set his sights on a new target. He is now attracted to a brand new young woman and we are curious to know who she is going to be!
15 Lucy Hale– Pretty Little Liars To YOU, Like Shay Mitchell
Lucy Hale and Shay Mitchell have something in common. They both starred on Pretty Little Liars together. It wouldn’t be such a stretch for Lucy Hale to star on a show like YOU, the way Mitchell did in season one of the show! Both shows are pretty dark if viewers really think about it.
14 Haley Lu Richardson– A Lovely Brunette For The Role
Haley Lu Richardson is an obvious candidate when it comes to selecting an actress to play the role of Joe’s next target in season three. She is a lovely brunette who has starred in movies like The Edge of Seventeen, 5 Feet Apart, Support the Girls, and so much more! We could easily see her in this role.
13 Jessica Lowndes– A Drop-Dead Gorgeous Obsession For Joe Goldberg
Jessica Lowndes is a drop-dead gorgeous option when it comes to someone that a character like Joe Goldberg could be obsessed with. Most people recognize her from her time on 90210 where she played the character of Adriana. She played that role from 2008 to 2013 and did an amazing job.
12 Nina Dobrev– She Can Handle Vampires So She Can Handle A Stalker
Nina Dobrev is the star of another intense teen TV show called The Vampire Diaries. It wouldn’t surprise us at all if she was the beautiful actress to be cast as Joe’s target in season three of YOU. She can handle vampires so we’re totally sure that she can handle a stalker like Joe Goldberg!
11 Phoebe Tonkin– Her Beautiful Eyes Would Mesmerize Joe Goldberg
The one thing that stands out most about a beautiful actress like Phoebe Tonkin is the fact that her eyes are so huge! They are so animated and lovely that she is hard to look away from. She is the type of woman that would totally captivate and mesmerize a guy like Joe Goldberg… We have no doubt about that!
10 Willa Holland– She Looks Like Joe Goldberg’s Type
Willa Holland totally looks like Joe Goldberg’s type. At one point in her acting career, she played the role of a model on Gossip Girl. Most recently she’s been part of the Arrowverse on the CW network. There doesn’t seem to be anything slowing her down so we hope to possibly see her in season three of YOU.
9 Sarah Hyland– Her Adorable Charm Would Fit The Role
Everyone knows Sarah Hyland from her time playing the older sister on Modern Family but now that Modern Family has come to an end, it’s time to see her in a new and interesting TV show like YOU. Her adorable charm would totally fit the role. There is something so likable about Sarah Hyland.
8 Lily Collins– Another Stunning Beauty For Joe Goldberg
Lily Collins is another stunning beauty that Joe Goldberg could totally fall for. Lily Collins is an incredible actress who has worked with the likes of Zac Efron, Taylor Lautner, and so many other handsome actors in her career. We can easily see her working alongside Penn Badgley too.
7 Elizabeth Gillies– Her Total Confidence Is So Obvious
Elizabeth Gillies has such a crazy amount of confidence that it completely blows us away! She is really gorgeous and her time on a show like Dynasty proves to us that she knows how to take on serious rules. Dynasty is such a dramatic TV show to watch and she fits that character dynamic perfectly.
6 Madison Beer– Anyone Would Obsess Over This Girl
Who wouldn’t obsess over a gorgeous young woman like Madison Beer? If Madison Beer snagged the role of Joe Goldberg’s newest target in season three of YOU, it would totally make sense. She is absolutely stunning and anyone who looks at her is instantly attracted to her!
5 Camila Mendes– Riverdale And YOU... Two Dark TV Shows
Camila Mendes is already the star of a dark TV show called Riverdale. She plays the role of Veronica Lodge. That being said, we can see her starring in a show like YOU since both shows are on the darker side. Camila Mendes has fully proven herself to be a lovely and incredible actress.
4 Maia Mitchell– Her Innocent Look Would Fit The Role
Maia Mitchell would be a great choice for Joe Goldberg's latest target in season three of YOU. Her innocent look would totally fit the role. She has a girl-next-door vibe that totally stands out. We’ve seen her on The Fosters before and it's time to see her take on a different role like this one.
3 Emilia Clarke– She Rocks Her Natural Brown Hair These Days
The whole world knows and loves Emilia Clarke from her time on Game of Thrones. When she was on Game of Thrones, she rocked bright platinum hair, but these days, she is wearing her natural brown hair. We know that Joe Goldberg’s next target is a brunette, so Emilia Clarke could be the one.
2 Ashley Greene– This Twilight Starlet Would Be Ideal
Ashley Greene is a Twilight starlet who would be ideal for this role. She played a vampire in the Twilight Saga and gathered a huge fan base because of it. These days we would totally love to see her in a new role… Joe Goldberg’s latest target would be a smart acting job for her to take!
1 Emma Watson– Joe Goldberg Would Easily Fall For Her
Emma Watson is an obvious choice when it comes to actresses who could play Joe Goldberg’s latest crush. A character like Joe Goldberg would easily fall for a girl played by Emma Watson because Emma Watson is the total package. She has a sweet personality and she is also very beautiful.